Following changes to its terms and conditions, many independent makers have removed their shops from Etsy. This raises questions around how much platforms should be able to claim usage rights over content created on their platforms to support AI.
On 26 th October, Etsy updated its terms of use, which came into effect on 16 th December. Section 5.C now means that Etsy, as well as its approved third party partners and vendors, can use content uploaded by sellers (images, copy, videos, and reviews) to “develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.” Although sellers retain ownership over their content, they are giving Etsy a very broad unlimited and irrevocable licence. For most sellers based in the US there is no easy way to withdraw their consent in their account settings. They must instead get in contact with Etsy’s Data Protection Officer. Previously there was no mention of AI in Etsy’s terms of service.
Concerns were heightened as these changes occurred shortly after tighter measures were placed on AI ‘slop’ listings on Etsy. Sellers must upload genuine un-edited images of products, and cannot include content generated by bots, or AI generated working guides, unless they clearly disclose this information. Makers are therefore concerned by what seems to be conflicting changes: Etsy is restricting how makers can use AI but increasing its use of makers’ original content to improve their AI models.
Many established sellers have removed their shops. Aaron Millard, an illustrator, removed his shop which he had run for almost 10 years, explaining that “I’m no long comfortable selling on Etsy. If I do, I’m allowing Etsy to use my art to train AI models, and possibly even sell the data to third parties.
There’s no simple way to decline this.” Cognitive Surplus, a seller of stationery and homeware items, also removed their shop from Etsy after 13 years. Similarly, creators of the webcomics War and Peas have also pulled out. Many have shared images explaining their withdrawal and directing customers to personal sites. In withdrawing from Etsy, they are losing valuable reviews, search optimisation and sales over the key festive period, but are taking back control over how their content is used.
James Ossman, Vice President of Customer Operations at Etsy commented on this concern. He explained that Etsy are not using sellers’ content to create AI models which mimic original creative content, and so this change is not a new policy but just clarification. Examples given of current uses include translating listings, displaying images in marketing materials, detecting fraudulent activity, and providing data to sellers to improve listings, or summarise performance. However, due to ongoing concern, Etsy have said they will make changes to the terms. A revised version will be sent out to sellers shortly.
Conclusion
This situation demonstrates a wider issue within the creator economy. While creators produce original content on platforms, they often have very little negotiation power when it comes to changes in terms. Even though sellers retain copyright over their content, giving Etsy (and partners) perpetual rights to use content for AI development can feel like they have lost control over their content in the future.
Particularly if many partners are involved and it is difficult to opt-out. Although Etsy have taken steps to address consumer concerns regarding mistruthful AI content (for example by placing restrictions around misleading listings), this clause has caused confusion for many creators.
It remains to be seen whether the changes will be sufficient to rebuild trust. Those who have already left may not return quickly. As a general trend we are seeing that marketplaces are attempting to gain clear rights to use content for AI, but creators are looking for clearer boundaries. Alongside this, as platforms rely on original human content, it may simply come down to a point where enough creators decide that terms are no longer favourable to them.
Source: Engadget

